{"id":349,"date":"2023-07-20T10:32:17","date_gmt":"2023-07-20T09:32:17","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/?page_id=349"},"modified":"2026-03-25T16:05:42","modified_gmt":"2026-03-25T16:05:42","slug":"programme-learning-outcomes","status":"publish","type":"page","link":"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/programme-development\/programme-learning-outcomes\/","title":{"rendered":"Programme Learning Outcomes"},"content":{"rendered":"<h2 id=\"section-1\">Getting started with Programme Learning Outcomes<\/h2>\n<h3>Introduction to the Four-Stage Process<\/h3>\n<p>Staff are advised to follow an outcomes-based approach to education, that is to directly align the learning outcomes of a course of study (at the programme and modular level) to assessment tasks, their marking and feedback, and teaching and learning activities (QAA). We embed this approach in the LTA by promoting this 4-stage process to programme development. Here we focus on the Programme Learning Outcomes, the first of the stages.<\/p>\n<p>See below for a diagram that explains the process.<\/p>\n<figure id=\"post-1404 media-1404\" class=\"image w-100 clearfix\"><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/files\/2023\/08\/4-Stage-1-PLOs.png\" alt=\"Process diagram for Program Development stages and process, highlighting the programme learning outcomes stage. This is the first stage. Following on from here is Programme Assessments, Module Learning Outcomes, and Module Assessments and Learning Activities.\" \/><\/figure>\n<p>Another aspect of this page to be aware of is the Holistic Template for Programme Development. We&#8217;ll be filling it in in increments across the four pages as part of this process. It is available in its entirety in the <a href=\"#section-5\">Deeper dive<\/a>.<\/p>\n<hr \/>\n<h3>What are Programme Learning Outcomes?<\/h3>\n<p>Learning outcomes are a clear, concise description of what a student should be able to demonstrate in terms of knowledge, understanding and behaviours at the end of a programme or module. Learning outcomes guide what and how we teach and assess, and therefore they should represent the core of what students learn. This process of alignment is called constructive alignment (Biggs, 1996) and is discussed further in the <a href=\"#section-5\">Deeper dive<\/a>.<\/p>\n<figure id=\"post-1780 media-1780\" class=\"image align-left\"><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/files\/2023\/08\/image-20221125152520-1.jpeg\" alt=\"Diagram of the constructive alignment model with its three components in a circle: learning outcomes, feedback and assessment methods, and teaching and learning activities\" \/><figcaption class=\"caption\">Constructive alignment process wheel diagram, highlighting learning outcomes.<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<hr \/>\n<h2 id=\"section-2\">Constructive alignment and PLOs<\/h2>\n \n\n                        <div class=\"alert alert-success with-icon \">        \n                            <div class=\"alert-icon\">\n                    <svg class=\"icon\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" viewBox=\"0 0 30 30\"><title>Globe<\/title><path d=\"M15,2a15,15,0,1,1,0,30A15,15,0,0,1,0,17,15,15,0,0,1,15,2ZM10.34,7.44L10,8a5.88,5.88,0,0,0-.31.63C9.53,9.06,9.31,9.53,9.16,10H14V4.16a2.78,2.78,0,0,0-.66.25,5,5,0,0,0-.69.41,6.52,6.52,0,0,0-1.22,1.09,10.24,10.24,0,0,0-1.09,1.53h0ZM16,10h4.84c-0.09-.22-0.16-0.47-0.25-0.69A12.87,12.87,0,0,0,20,8a5.49,5.49,0,0,1-.34-0.56,10.13,10.13,0,0,0-1.09-1.53,6.55,6.55,0,0,0-1.22-1.09,7.68,7.68,0,0,0-.66-0.41A3.67,3.67,0,0,0,16,4.16V10h0ZM5.81,7.81q-0.52.52-.94,1C4.59,9.22,4.28,9.63,4,10H7A15.68,15.68,0,0,1,8.09,7.44,11.33,11.33,0,0,1,9.41,5.28,11.54,11.54,0,0,0,7.5,6.38,10.52,10.52,0,0,0,5.81,7.81ZM23,10h3c-0.25-.37-0.56-0.78-0.84-1.16a13.7,13.7,0,0,0-.94-1A10.58,10.58,0,0,0,22.5,6.38a11.51,11.51,0,0,0-1.91-1.09,13.28,13.28,0,0,1,1.34,2.16A19,19,0,0,1,23,10h0ZM6.5,12H3a9,9,0,0,0-.62,2A10.61,10.61,0,0,0,2,16H6a14.66,14.66,0,0,1,.16-2.06c0.09-.66.19-1.31,0.31-1.94h0ZM14,12H8.56c-0.16.63-.25,1.31-0.34,2A10.67,10.67,0,0,0,8,16h6V12h0Zm2,0v4h6a14.19,14.19,0,0,0-.16-2c-0.12-.66-0.22-1.34-0.37-2H16Zm8,4h4a13.75,13.75,0,0,0-.31-2A11.21,11.21,0,0,0,27,12H23.5c0.13,0.63.22,1.28,0.31,1.94A14.51,14.51,0,0,1,24,16h0ZM3,22H6.5c-0.12-.62-0.22-1.28-0.31-1.94A14.51,14.51,0,0,1,6,18H2a10.6,10.6,0,0,0,.34,2A9,9,0,0,0,3,22H3Zm11-4H8a10.67,10.67,0,0,0,.19,2c0.09,0.66.19,1.34,0.34,2H14V18h0Zm2,4h5.44c0.16-.62.25-1.31,0.38-2A14.06,14.06,0,0,0,22,18H16v4Zm7.5,0H27a11.21,11.21,0,0,0,.66-2A13.9,13.9,0,0,0,28,18H24a14.66,14.66,0,0,1-.16,2.06c-0.09.66-.19,1.31-0.31,1.94h0ZM7,24H4c0.25,0.38.56,0.78,0.84,1.13a9.9,9.9,0,0,0,.94,1.06A10.58,10.58,0,0,0,7.5,27.63a11.51,11.51,0,0,0,1.91,1.09,11.33,11.33,0,0,1-1.31-2.16A15.79,15.79,0,0,1,7,24H7Zm2.12,0,0.28,0.69A7,7,0,0,0,10,26c0.09,0.22.22,0.41,0.31,0.59a9.78,9.78,0,0,0,1.09,1.5,6.78,6.78,0,0,0,1.22,1.13,3,3,0,0,0,.69.38,2,2,0,0,0,.66.28V24H9.16Zm10.5,2.56c0.09-.19.22-0.37,0.34-0.59s0.22-.41.31-0.62c0.19-.44.38-0.87,0.53-1.34H16v5.84a2.45,2.45,0,0,0,.69-0.28,3.51,3.51,0,0,0,.66-0.37,6.78,6.78,0,0,0,1.22-1.12,9.78,9.78,0,0,0,1.09-1.5h0Zm4.53-.37a10,10,0,0,0,.94-1.06c0.28-.34.59-0.75,0.84-1.12H23a19.07,19.07,0,0,1-1,2.56,13.28,13.28,0,0,1-1.34,2.16,11.54,11.54,0,0,0,1.91-1.09,10.52,10.52,0,0,0,1.69-1.44h0Z\" transform=\"translate(0 -2)\"><\/path><\/svg>                <\/div>\n            \n            <div class=\"alert-body\">            \n                <h3>Points for Reflection<\/h3>                <p>Questions to consider when applying Constructive Alignment to curriculum design:<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li>What are the desired or intended outcomes? <\/li>\n<li>What assessment tasks will tell you if the actual results match those that are intended or desired? <\/li>\n<li>What are the core outcomes all students should be able to perform?<\/li>\n<li>What teaching methods require students to behave in ways that are likely to achieve those outcomes? <\/li>\n<\/ul>\n            <\/div>\n        <\/div> \n\n    \n \n\n                        <div class=\"alert alert with-icon \">        \n                            <div class=\"alert-icon\">\n                    <svg class=\"icon\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" xmlns:xlink=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/1999\/xlink\" viewBox=\"0 0 793 696\" shape-rendering=\"geometricPrecision\" text-rendering=\"geometricPrecision\"><defs><linearGradient id=\"etZNF97Wf1q3-fill\" x1=\"351.931\" y1=\"516.34\" x2=\"670.917\" y2=\"516.34\" spreadMethod=\"pad\" gradientUnits=\"userSpaceOnUse\" gradientTransform=\"translate(0 0)\"><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q3-fill-0\" offset=\"0%\" stop-color=\"#12d69e\"\/><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q3-fill-1\" offset=\"100%\" stop-color=\"#00a870\"\/><\/linearGradient><linearGradient id=\"etZNF97Wf1q4-fill\" x1=\"0\" y1=\"153.98\" x2=\"318.986\" y2=\"153.98\" spreadMethod=\"pad\" gradientUnits=\"userSpaceOnUse\" gradientTransform=\"translate(0 0)\"><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q4-fill-0\" offset=\"0%\" stop-color=\"#02beff\"\/><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q4-fill-1\" offset=\"100%\" stop-color=\"#009dc1\"\/><\/linearGradient><linearGradient id=\"etZNF97Wf1q5-fill\" x1=\"-0.199167\" y1=\"512.304\" x2=\"309.144\" y2=\"512.304\" spreadMethod=\"pad\" gradientUnits=\"userSpaceOnUse\" gradientTransform=\"translate(0 0)\"><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q5-fill-0\" offset=\"0%\" stop-color=\"#fecb4d\"\/><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q5-fill-1\" offset=\"100%\" stop-color=\"#f49d03\"\/><\/linearGradient><linearGradient id=\"etZNF97Wf1q6-fill\" x1=\"361.627\" y1=\"159.063\" x2=\"671.043\" y2=\"159.063\" spreadMethod=\"pad\" gradientUnits=\"userSpaceOnUse\" gradientTransform=\"translate(0 0)\"><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q6-fill-0\" offset=\"0%\" stop-color=\"#ff6969\"\/><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q6-fill-1\" offset=\"100%\" stop-color=\"#fc3838\"\/><\/linearGradient><\/defs><g transform=\"translate(-489-1740)\"><path d=\"M636.253,636.253c47.169-47.169,47.169-122.638,0-168.759L536.675,366.868c-4.193-4.193-8.386-5.241-13.627-5.241s-9.433,2.096-13.626,5.241c-8.386,7.337-7.338,20.963,0,28.301l53.458,53.458c2.096,2.096,3.144,7.337,1.048,9.433-3.145,3.145-7.338,3.145-10.482,1.048L469.59,375.253c-4.192-4.193-8.385-5.241-13.626-5.241s-9.434,2.096-13.627,5.241c-8.385,7.337-7.337,20.964,0,28.301l82.808,82.808c3.144,3.144,3.144,7.337,0,10.481-3.145,3.145-7.338,3.145-10.482,0L404.602,384.687c-4.192-4.193-8.385-5.241-13.626-5.241s-9.434,2.096-13.627,5.241c-7.337,7.337-7.337,19.915,0,27.253L488.458,523.048c2.096,2.097,3.144,7.338,1.048,9.434-3.144,3.145-7.337,3.145-10.482,1.048l-94.337-93.289c-4.193-4.193-8.386-5.241-13.627-5.241s-9.433,2.096-13.626,5.241c-7.338,7.337-7.338,19.916,0,27.253l121.59,121.59c7.338,7.338-1.048,20.964-10.482,16.771l-37.735-14.674c-5.241-2.097-10.482-2.097-14.674,0-4.193,2.096-8.386,5.241-10.482,10.482-4.193,10.482,1.048,20.964,10.482,25.156l91.192,35.639c44.024,17.819,94.338,7.337,128.928-26.205v0Z\" transform=\"matrix(1.13937 0 0 1 503.331 1752.58)\" fill=\"url(#etZNF97Wf1q3-fill)\"\/><path d=\"M34.5904,34.5904c-47.1687,47.1686-47.1687,122.6386,0,168.7586l99.5786,99.579c4.192,4.193,8.385,5.241,13.626,5.241s9.434-2.097,13.627-5.241c8.385-7.338,7.337-20.964,0-28.301l-53.458-53.458c-3.145-1.049-3.145-6.289-1.048-8.386c3.144-3.144,7.337-3.144,10.482-1.048l83.855,83.855c4.193,4.193,8.386,5.241,13.627,5.241c5.24,0,9.433-2.096,13.626-5.241c8.386-7.337,7.337-20.963,0-28.301l-82.807-82.807c-3.145-3.145-3.145-7.337,0-10.482c3.144-3.145,7.337-3.145,10.482,0L267.289,285.108c4.193,4.193,8.386,5.241,13.627,5.241s9.433-2.096,13.626-5.241c7.338-7.337,7.338-19.915,0-27.253L182.386,147.795c-2.097-2.096-3.145-7.337-1.049-9.434c3.145-3.144,7.338-3.144,10.482-1.048l93.289,93.289c4.193,4.193,8.386,5.241,13.627,5.241s9.434-2.096,13.626-5.241c7.338-7.337,7.338-19.915,0-27.253L191.819,81.759c-7.337-7.3373,1.048-20.9638,10.482-16.771l37.735,14.6747c5.241,2.0963,10.482,2.0963,14.675,0c4.193-2.0964,8.385-5.241,10.482-10.482c4.193-10.4819-1.048-20.9638-10.482-25.1566L163.518,8.38554C119.494,-9.43374,69.1807,1.04819,34.5904,34.5904v0Z\" transform=\"matrix(1.13937 0 0 1 503.331 1752.58)\" fill=\"url(#etZNF97Wf1q4-fill)\"\/><path d=\"M34.5904,636.253c47.1686,47.169,122.6386,47.169,168.7586,0l99.579-99.578c4.193-4.193,5.241-8.386,5.241-13.627s-2.097-9.433-5.241-13.626c-7.338-8.386-20.964-7.338-28.301,0L221.169,562.88c-1.049,3.144-6.289,3.144-8.386,1.048-3.144-3.145-3.144-7.338-1.048-10.482L295.59,469.59c4.193-4.192,5.241-8.385,5.241-13.626s-2.096-9.434-5.241-13.627c-7.337-8.385-20.963-7.337-28.301,0l-82.807,82.808c-3.145,3.144-7.337,3.144-10.482,0-3.145-3.145-3.145-7.338,0-10.482L285.108,403.554c4.193-4.193,5.241-8.385,5.241-13.626s-2.096-9.434-5.241-13.627c-7.337-7.337-19.915-7.337-27.253,0L147.795,488.458c-2.096,2.096-7.337,3.144-9.434,1.048-3.144-3.144-3.144-7.337-1.048-10.482l93.289-93.289c4.193-4.193,5.241-8.386,5.241-13.627c0-5.24-2.096-9.433-5.241-13.626-7.337-7.337-19.915-7.337-27.253,0L81.759,479.024c-7.3373,7.338-20.9638-1.048-16.771-10.482l14.6747-37.735c2.0963-5.241,2.0963-10.482,0-14.674-2.0964-4.193-5.241-8.386-10.482-10.482-10.4819-4.193-20.9638,1.048-25.1566,10.482L8.38554,507.325C-9.43374,551.349,1.04819,601.663,34.5904,636.253v0Z\" transform=\"matrix(1.13937 0 0 1 503.331 1752.58)\" fill=\"url(#etZNF97Wf1q5-fill)\"\/><path d=\"M636.253,34.5904c-47.169-47.1687-122.638-47.1687-168.759,0L366.868,134.169c-4.193,4.192-5.241,8.385-5.241,13.626s2.096,9.434,5.241,13.627c7.337,8.385,20.963,7.337,28.301,0l53.458-53.458c2.096-2.097,7.337-3.145,9.433-1.048c3.145,3.144,3.145,7.337,1.048,10.482l-83.855,83.855c-4.193,4.193-5.241,8.386-5.241,13.627c0,5.24,2.096,9.433,5.241,13.626c7.337,8.386,20.964,7.337,28.301,0l82.808-82.807c3.144-3.145,7.337-3.145,10.481,0c3.145,3.144,3.145,7.337,0,10.482L384.687,266.241c-4.193,4.193-5.241,8.386-5.241,13.626c0,5.241,2.096,9.434,5.241,13.627c7.337,7.337,19.915,7.337,27.253,0L523.048,182.386c2.097-2.097,7.338-3.145,9.434-1.049c3.145,3.145,3.145,7.338,1.048,10.482l-93.289,94.338c-4.193,4.192-5.241,8.385-5.241,13.626s2.096,9.434,5.241,13.627c7.337,7.337,19.916,7.337,27.253,0l121.59-121.591c7.338-7.337,20.964,1.048,16.771,10.482l-14.674,37.735c-2.097,5.241-2.097,10.482,0,14.675c2.096,4.193,5.241,8.385,10.482,10.482c10.482,4.193,20.964-1.048,25.156-10.482l35.639-91.193c17.819-44.024,7.337-94.3373-26.205-128.9276v0Z\" transform=\"matrix(1.13937 0 0 1 503.331 1752.58)\" fill=\"url(#etZNF97Wf1q6-fill)\"\/><\/g><\/svg>                <\/div>\n            \n            <div class=\"alert-body\">            \n                <h3>Inclusivity Tip<\/h3>                <p>When designing outcomes, you are creating the conditions by which all students will be assessed, either formatively or summatively, whether they achieve a third or a first.<\/p>\n<p>You may have other ambitions for creativity, lateral thinking, application or production \u2013 these are extension activities, and while important and valid aspirations for your programme, module or session, these are beyond the competence standards for the programme, and the key learning outcomes for a module or programme, which are the indicators of success for <em>all<\/em> students on the module.<\/p>\n<p>In identifying the key learning outcomes, you and your students will be able to establish and clarify expectations for the programme, module, or session.<\/p>\n<p>Oxford Brookes offer some practical considerations for ensuring inclusivity in your Learning Outcomes in this <a href=\"https:\/\/www.brookes.ac.uk\/documents\/ocsld\/inclusive-guides\/outcomes\/\">PDF.<\/a><\/p>\n<p>You can read more on our <a href=\"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/theme-overview\/inclusivity\/empowering-students-to-fulfil-their-potential\/\">Empowering Students to fulfil their potential page.<\/a><\/p>\n            <\/div>\n        <\/div> \n\n    \n<h3>Why are Learning Outcomes so important?<\/h3>\n<p>Learning Outcomes perform a number of crucial functions in the design, delivery and marketing of courses. They:<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li>clearly communicate expectations to learners;<\/li>\n<li>clearly communicate graduates\u2019 skills to prospective employers;<\/li>\n<li>define coherent units of learning that can be further subdivided or modularized for classroom or for other delivery modes;<\/li>\n<li>define the type and depth of learning students are expected to achieve;<\/li>\n<li>provide an objective benchmark for formative, summative, and prior learning assessment;<\/li>\n<li>guide and organise the instructor and the learner.<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>In this toolkit we embrace \u2018<a href=\"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/programme-development\/programme-assessment\/\">backward design<\/a>\u2019 \u2013 here we see the programme learning outcomes guiding a programmatic assessment approach. Module learning outcomes and module assessments are then engineered to support achievement of those assessment tasks, and by turn achieve the Programme Learning Outcomes, represented visually below:<\/p>\n<figure id=\"post-1800 media-1800\" class=\"image w-100 clearfix\"><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/files\/2023\/08\/Four-Step-overview.png\" alt=\"Process diagram for Programme Development stages and processes. The first is programme learning outcomes. Following on from here is Programme Assessments, Module Learning Outcomes, and Module Assessments and Learning Activities.\" \/><\/figure>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<h3>Programme and Module Learning Outcomes<\/h3>\n<p>Learning Outcomes are set at both programme and module level.<\/p>\n<p>Programme Learning Outcomes describe what a student will be able to do (and become) as a result of their programme of study at Cardiff University. They will help students understand what is expected of them at the programme level. Hence, it is important that they are written FOR your students, that they are aligned to the assessments students will undertake (to allow students to demonstrate their achievement of the outcomes), and that they are not simply a list of \u2018teaching intentions\u2019. Programme learning outcomes need to be set at the level of the award, in line with <a href=\"https:\/\/www.qaa.ac.uk\/quality-code\/qualifications-frameworks\">FHEQ level descriptors<\/a> and, where appropriate, be aligned with the attributes, skills, and abilities expected within that discipline, as defined in the relevant <a href=\"https:\/\/www.qaa.ac.uk\/quality-code\/subject-benchmark-statements\">QAA Subject Benchmark Statements<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p>Similarly, module learning outcomes identify the smaller (more) discrete outcomes that a student will be expected to demonstrate their achievement of within an individual module. These also need to be (constructively) aligned to the module aim and assessment strategies.<\/p>\n \n\n                        <div class=\"alert alert alert-info with-icon \">        \n                            <div class=\"alert-icon\">\n                    <svg class=\"icon\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" xmlns:xlink=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/1999\/xlink\" viewBox=\"0 0 793 696\" shape-rendering=\"geometricPrecision\" text-rendering=\"geometricPrecision\"><defs><linearGradient id=\"etZNF97Wf1q3-fill\" x1=\"351.931\" y1=\"516.34\" x2=\"670.917\" y2=\"516.34\" spreadMethod=\"pad\" gradientUnits=\"userSpaceOnUse\" gradientTransform=\"translate(0 0)\"><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q3-fill-0\" offset=\"0%\" stop-color=\"#12d69e\"\/><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q3-fill-1\" offset=\"100%\" stop-color=\"#00a870\"\/><\/linearGradient><linearGradient id=\"etZNF97Wf1q4-fill\" x1=\"0\" y1=\"153.98\" x2=\"318.986\" y2=\"153.98\" spreadMethod=\"pad\" gradientUnits=\"userSpaceOnUse\" gradientTransform=\"translate(0 0)\"><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q4-fill-0\" offset=\"0%\" stop-color=\"#02beff\"\/><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q4-fill-1\" offset=\"100%\" stop-color=\"#009dc1\"\/><\/linearGradient><linearGradient id=\"etZNF97Wf1q5-fill\" x1=\"-0.199167\" y1=\"512.304\" x2=\"309.144\" y2=\"512.304\" spreadMethod=\"pad\" gradientUnits=\"userSpaceOnUse\" gradientTransform=\"translate(0 0)\"><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q5-fill-0\" offset=\"0%\" stop-color=\"#fecb4d\"\/><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q5-fill-1\" offset=\"100%\" stop-color=\"#f49d03\"\/><\/linearGradient><linearGradient id=\"etZNF97Wf1q6-fill\" x1=\"361.627\" y1=\"159.063\" x2=\"671.043\" y2=\"159.063\" spreadMethod=\"pad\" gradientUnits=\"userSpaceOnUse\" gradientTransform=\"translate(0 0)\"><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q6-fill-0\" offset=\"0%\" stop-color=\"#ff6969\"\/><stop id=\"etZNF97Wf1q6-fill-1\" offset=\"100%\" stop-color=\"#fc3838\"\/><\/linearGradient><\/defs><g transform=\"translate(-489-1740)\"><path d=\"M636.253,636.253c47.169-47.169,47.169-122.638,0-168.759L536.675,366.868c-4.193-4.193-8.386-5.241-13.627-5.241s-9.433,2.096-13.626,5.241c-8.386,7.337-7.338,20.963,0,28.301l53.458,53.458c2.096,2.096,3.144,7.337,1.048,9.433-3.145,3.145-7.338,3.145-10.482,1.048L469.59,375.253c-4.192-4.193-8.385-5.241-13.626-5.241s-9.434,2.096-13.627,5.241c-8.385,7.337-7.337,20.964,0,28.301l82.808,82.808c3.144,3.144,3.144,7.337,0,10.481-3.145,3.145-7.338,3.145-10.482,0L404.602,384.687c-4.192-4.193-8.385-5.241-13.626-5.241s-9.434,2.096-13.627,5.241c-7.337,7.337-7.337,19.915,0,27.253L488.458,523.048c2.096,2.097,3.144,7.338,1.048,9.434-3.144,3.145-7.337,3.145-10.482,1.048l-94.337-93.289c-4.193-4.193-8.386-5.241-13.627-5.241s-9.433,2.096-13.626,5.241c-7.338,7.337-7.338,19.916,0,27.253l121.59,121.59c7.338,7.338-1.048,20.964-10.482,16.771l-37.735-14.674c-5.241-2.097-10.482-2.097-14.674,0-4.193,2.096-8.386,5.241-10.482,10.482-4.193,10.482,1.048,20.964,10.482,25.156l91.192,35.639c44.024,17.819,94.338,7.337,128.928-26.205v0Z\" transform=\"matrix(1.13937 0 0 1 503.331 1752.58)\" fill=\"url(#etZNF97Wf1q3-fill)\"\/><path d=\"M34.5904,34.5904c-47.1687,47.1686-47.1687,122.6386,0,168.7586l99.5786,99.579c4.192,4.193,8.385,5.241,13.626,5.241s9.434-2.097,13.627-5.241c8.385-7.338,7.337-20.964,0-28.301l-53.458-53.458c-3.145-1.049-3.145-6.289-1.048-8.386c3.144-3.144,7.337-3.144,10.482-1.048l83.855,83.855c4.193,4.193,8.386,5.241,13.627,5.241c5.24,0,9.433-2.096,13.626-5.241c8.386-7.337,7.337-20.963,0-28.301l-82.807-82.807c-3.145-3.145-3.145-7.337,0-10.482c3.144-3.145,7.337-3.145,10.482,0L267.289,285.108c4.193,4.193,8.386,5.241,13.627,5.241s9.433-2.096,13.626-5.241c7.338-7.337,7.338-19.915,0-27.253L182.386,147.795c-2.097-2.096-3.145-7.337-1.049-9.434c3.145-3.144,7.338-3.144,10.482-1.048l93.289,93.289c4.193,4.193,8.386,5.241,13.627,5.241s9.434-2.096,13.626-5.241c7.338-7.337,7.338-19.915,0-27.253L191.819,81.759c-7.337-7.3373,1.048-20.9638,10.482-16.771l37.735,14.6747c5.241,2.0963,10.482,2.0963,14.675,0c4.193-2.0964,8.385-5.241,10.482-10.482c4.193-10.4819-1.048-20.9638-10.482-25.1566L163.518,8.38554C119.494,-9.43374,69.1807,1.04819,34.5904,34.5904v0Z\" transform=\"matrix(1.13937 0 0 1 503.331 1752.58)\" fill=\"url(#etZNF97Wf1q4-fill)\"\/><path d=\"M34.5904,636.253c47.1686,47.169,122.6386,47.169,168.7586,0l99.579-99.578c4.193-4.193,5.241-8.386,5.241-13.627s-2.097-9.433-5.241-13.626c-7.338-8.386-20.964-7.338-28.301,0L221.169,562.88c-1.049,3.144-6.289,3.144-8.386,1.048-3.144-3.145-3.144-7.338-1.048-10.482L295.59,469.59c4.193-4.192,5.241-8.385,5.241-13.626s-2.096-9.434-5.241-13.627c-7.337-8.385-20.963-7.337-28.301,0l-82.807,82.808c-3.145,3.144-7.337,3.144-10.482,0-3.145-3.145-3.145-7.338,0-10.482L285.108,403.554c4.193-4.193,5.241-8.385,5.241-13.626s-2.096-9.434-5.241-13.627c-7.337-7.337-19.915-7.337-27.253,0L147.795,488.458c-2.096,2.096-7.337,3.144-9.434,1.048-3.144-3.144-3.144-7.337-1.048-10.482l93.289-93.289c4.193-4.193,5.241-8.386,5.241-13.627c0-5.24-2.096-9.433-5.241-13.626-7.337-7.337-19.915-7.337-27.253,0L81.759,479.024c-7.3373,7.338-20.9638-1.048-16.771-10.482l14.6747-37.735c2.0963-5.241,2.0963-10.482,0-14.674-2.0964-4.193-5.241-8.386-10.482-10.482-10.4819-4.193-20.9638,1.048-25.1566,10.482L8.38554,507.325C-9.43374,551.349,1.04819,601.663,34.5904,636.253v0Z\" transform=\"matrix(1.13937 0 0 1 503.331 1752.58)\" fill=\"url(#etZNF97Wf1q5-fill)\"\/><path d=\"M636.253,34.5904c-47.169-47.1687-122.638-47.1687-168.759,0L366.868,134.169c-4.193,4.192-5.241,8.385-5.241,13.626s2.096,9.434,5.241,13.627c7.337,8.385,20.963,7.337,28.301,0l53.458-53.458c2.096-2.097,7.337-3.145,9.433-1.048c3.145,3.144,3.145,7.337,1.048,10.482l-83.855,83.855c-4.193,4.193-5.241,8.386-5.241,13.627c0,5.24,2.096,9.433,5.241,13.626c7.337,8.386,20.964,7.337,28.301,0l82.808-82.807c3.144-3.145,7.337-3.145,10.481,0c3.145,3.144,3.145,7.337,0,10.482L384.687,266.241c-4.193,4.193-5.241,8.386-5.241,13.626c0,5.241,2.096,9.434,5.241,13.627c7.337,7.337,19.915,7.337,27.253,0L523.048,182.386c2.097-2.097,7.338-3.145,9.434-1.049c3.145,3.145,3.145,7.338,1.048,10.482l-93.289,94.338c-4.193,4.192-5.241,8.385-5.241,13.626s2.096,9.434,5.241,13.627c7.337,7.337,19.916,7.337,27.253,0l121.59-121.591c7.338-7.337,20.964,1.048,16.771,10.482l-14.674,37.735c-2.097,5.241-2.097,10.482,0,14.675c2.096,4.193,5.241,8.385,10.482,10.482c10.482,4.193,20.964-1.048,25.156-10.482l35.639-91.193c17.819-44.024,7.337-94.3373-26.205-128.9276v0Z\" transform=\"matrix(1.13937 0 0 1 503.331 1752.58)\" fill=\"url(#etZNF97Wf1q6-fill)\"\/><\/g><\/svg>                <\/div>\n            \n            <div class=\"alert-body\">            \n                <h3>Inclusive Learning Outcomes<\/h3>                <p class=\"MsoNormal\"><span lang=\"EN-US\">Check that your learning outcomes don\u2019t inadvertently exclude students for reasons that aren\u2019t strictly necessary or related to the programme or disciplinary area competence standards. <\/span><\/p>\n<p class=\"MsoNormal\"><span lang=\"EN-US\">For example, if you require students to demonstrate specific skills in literacy, social aptitude, communication or manual dexterity, some of your learners may be at a disadvantage. Some of these will be essential competence standards for your programme, but otherwise, it may be possible to design out these requirements, or make individual adjustments for some learners. For more information, read <a href=\"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/theme-overview\/inclusivity\/empowering-students-to-fulfil-their-potential\/\">our Inclusive Programme Design section on the Empowering Students to Fulfil their Potential page.<\/a><\/span><\/p>\n            <\/div>\n        <\/div> \n\n    \n<h3>The relationship between Programme and Module Learning Outcomes<\/h3>\n<p>The following infographic offers information on the differences and similarities between Programme and Module Learning Outcomes. VASCULAR refers to a <a href=\"https:\/\/thesedablog.wordpress.com\/2019\/03\/07\/sally-brown\/\">progressive approach to writing Learning Outcomes proposed by Sally Brown<\/a>: feel free to read this in order to develop your understanding further and contact the CLTA if you&#8217;d like to know more.<\/p>\n<figure id=\"post-1788 media-1788\" class=\"image w-75 clearfix\"><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/files\/2023\/08\/VASCULAR.png\" alt=\"A Venn diagram showing the similarities and differences between Programme Learning Outcomes and Module Learning Outcomes. The Programme Learning Outcome qualities are as follows. PLOs describe what students will know and be able to do on completion of a programme. PLOs should be aligned with institutional graduate attributes. PLOs should make clear what is unique about the programme. PLOs should be aligned with learning and teaching activities across the programme. The Module Learning Outcome qualities are listed as follows. MLOs should be focused on what a student will learn from a specific module. MLOs should be unique to each module. MLOs should be centred around the skills, knowledge and behaviours of a graduate of the programme. MLOs should be aligned with module assessment methods and criteria. The shared qualities between programme and learning outcomes are listed as follows. Both PLOs and MLOs should be appropriate to level of study, expressed in a way students can understand and reviewed regularly. They both should also be \u2018VASCULAR\u2019. VASCULAR is a mnemonic for a progressive approach to creating learning outcomes as suggested by Sally Brown. It stands for: Verifiable, Action-Orientated, Singular, Constructively Aligned, Understandable, Level-Appropriate, Affective-Inclusive, Regularly reviewed.\" \/><\/figure>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<hr \/>\n<h2 id=\"section-3\">How to write PLOs<\/h2>\n<h3>Categories of Learning Outcomes<\/h3>\n<p>As suggested in the CLTA Programme Development Process, and as required for Quality Assurance, good learning outcomes refer to a range of different ways of demonstrating achievement:<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li>Knowledge and Understanding (KU)<\/li>\n<li>Intellectual Skills (IS)<\/li>\n<li>Professional Practical Skills (PS)<\/li>\n<li>Transferable \/ Key Skills (KS)<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n \n\n                        <div class=\"alert alert alert-error with-icon \">        \n                            <div class=\"alert-icon\">\n                    <svg class=\"icon\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" xmlns:xlink=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/1999\/xlink\" viewBox=\"0 0 196 148\" shape-rendering=\"geometricPrecision\" text-rendering=\"geometricPrecision\"><g clip-rule=\"evenodd\"><path d=\"M37.5,-0.5c44,0,88,0,132,0c.283.78913.783,1.455796,1.5,2c.667,44,.667,88,0,132-10.418.987-20.918,1.32-31.5,1c.167-26.669,0-53.3354-.5-80-31.035,30.868-61.8682,61.868-92.5,93-.6667,0-1.3333,0-2,0-6.6307-7.132-13.4641-14.132-20.5-21-.6667-.667-.6667-1.333,0-2C54.8333,93.6667,85.6667,62.8333,116.5,32c-26.6646-.5-53.3313-.6666-80-.5-.3091-10.7483.0242-21.415,1-32Z\" opacity=\"0.967\" clip-rule=\"evenodd\" fill=\"#fefffe\" fill-rule=\"evenodd\"\/><\/g><\/svg>                <\/div>\n            \n            <div class=\"alert-body\">            \n                <h3>Employability Tip<\/h3>                <p>These learning outcomes should be mapped to the <a href=\"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/theme-overview\/employability\/graduate-attributes\/\">graduate attributes<\/a>. These will then inform your approach to programmatic assessment and be embedded in module learning outcomes. These are shown below.<\/p>\n<figure id=\"post-1241 media-1241\" class=\"image w-100 clearfix\"><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/files\/2023\/08\/Picture-1.png\" alt=\"A decorative representation of the Graduate Attributes. Effective Communicators is represented by a student working in augmented reality wearing a black headset. Reflective and resilient is represented by a fingers posed to create a lens through which a field can be seen. Ethically, Socially and Environmentally Aware is represented by a hand holding a small globe against a blue sky. Innovative, Enterprising and Commercially Aware is represented by a low-angle of silver sky-scrapers. Independent and Critical Thinkers is represented by paperclips hanging like light bulbs in rising in height diagonally \u2013 the last of the 5 is depicted as a glowing yellow bulb. Collaborative is represented as a low-angled view of 5 smiling students.\" \/><\/figure>\n            <\/div>\n        <\/div> \n\n    \n<h3>Writing effective PLOs<\/h3>\n<div style=\"border: 2px solid black;padding: 10px;float: left\">\u2757 This content is repeated in the Module Learning Outcomes page, owing to the similarities in writing Programme and Module Learning Outcomes<\/div>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>To ensure that your learning outcomes are student focused, it can be useful to try and put yourself in the students&#8217; shoes and to think about how you might respond to these as a student. Learning outcomes are normally made up of three elements.<\/p>\n<figure id=\"post-1795 media-1795\" class=\"image w-50 clearfix\"><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/files\/2023\/08\/Verb-context-subject.png\" alt=\"Represented as a Venn diagram, verb, context and subject are all shown to be crucial elements to writing a Programme Learning Outcome.\" \/><\/figure>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<ol>\n<li>A <strong>verb<\/strong> to define the specific action that students to demonstrate their learning.<\/li>\n<li>A <strong>subject<\/strong>, to specify the subject material you want the learning to cover.<\/li>\n<li>The <strong>context<\/strong> of the learning is sometimes included to give more detail about where or how the learning might be demonstrated, or the standard that must be reached to pass.<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<p>Let&#8217;s see that in practical terms:<\/p>\n<ol>\n<li>An <span style=\"color: green\">action<\/span> that can be verified empirically, by \u2018the evidence of your eyes and ears\u2019;<\/li>\n<li>A <span style=\"color: red\">subject<\/span>: the given;<\/li>\n<li><em><span style=\"color: purple\">Performance criteria<\/span><\/em> to contextualise the learning (may be implicit).<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<p><strong>Examples<\/strong>:<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li><strong><span style=\"color: green\">Compile<\/span><\/strong><span style=\"color: #ff0000\"><strong>\u202f<\/strong><span style=\"color: #800080\"><em>independent<\/em><\/span> research<\/span> <em><span style=\"color: purple\">which encompasses a wide range of relevant methodologies and resources<\/span>.<\/em><\/li>\n<li><strong><span style=\"color: green\">Demonstrate<\/span><\/strong> <em><span style=\"color: purple\">a critical understanding<\/span><\/em> of <span style=\"color: red\">the technological aspects of imaging modalities, including the use of pharmacological agents, to assist with procedures<\/span>.<\/li>\n<li><strong><span style=\"color: green\">Communicate<\/span><\/strong><span style=\"color: purple\"><span style=\"color: red\"> about public health issues<em> <span style=\"color: #800080\">to a variety of specialist and non-specialist audiences<\/span><\/em><\/span><\/span><\/li>\n<li><strong><span style=\"color: #008000\">Articulate<\/span><\/strong><span style=\"color: #ff0000\"> a personal and critical stance<\/span> in <em><span style=\"color: #800080\">relation to relevant linguistic arguments.<\/span><\/em><\/li>\n<li><span style=\"color: #008000\"><strong>Defend<\/strong> <span style=\"color: #ff0000\">proposed business change solutions to<\/span><\/span><em>\u00a0<span style=\"color: #ff0000\"><span style=\"color: #800080\">complex problems in real-world business contexts<\/span><\/span><\/em><\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>Intended outcomes should always be assessable, so their wording needs to reflect the skills and behaviours students should be able to demonstrate on successful completion of the programme\/module.<\/p>\n<hr \/>\n<h2 id=\"section-4\">Categories of PLOs<\/h2>\n<p>Using the example of developing a programme in MSc Rocket Science drag and drop the Learning Outcome into one Graduate Attribute that you feel is best met by these programme outcomes. In reality there will be many more than one Graduate Attribute which may be relevant to each Learning Outcome, but this activity is for illustrative purposes, so pick what you believe is the most obvious fit.<\/p>\n\n<!-- iframe plugin v.6.0 wordpress.org\/plugins\/iframe\/ -->\n<iframe loading=\"lazy\" src=\"https:\/\/xerte.cardiff.ac.uk\/play_19028#page1\" width=\"100%\" height=\"500\" scrolling=\"yes\" class=\"iframe-class\" frameborder=\"0\"><\/iframe>\n\n<p><a href=\"https:\/\/xerte.cardiff.ac.uk\/play_19028\">Click here to play in full screen mode<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p>To do an <a href=\"https:\/\/cf-my.sharepoint.com\/:w:\/g\/personal\/huggett-fieldhousea_cardiff_ac_uk\/EQeDL5_B8J1OjPKsKsdn-yYBJGBqSuMm5MPZDA1c7pg3cw?e=LxqJR0\">alternative version in Word which can be read by a screenreader, click here<\/a>.<\/p>\n<hr \/>\n<h2 id=\"section-5\">Deeper dive<\/h2>\n<div class=\"accordion accordion-accessible\"><div class=\"accordion-section\">\n        <h2 class=\"accordion-section-header-title collapsed\" data-toggle=\"collapse\" href=\"#content-programme-learning-outcomes-deeper-dive-1\"\n        aria-expanded=\"false\"><svg class=\"icon icon-chevron-right\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" viewBox=\"0 0 19.75 32\">\n    <title>Chevron right<\/title>\n    <path d=\"M6.13,28.28L18.41,16,6.13,3.72,9.84,0l16,16-16,16Z\" transform=\"translate(-6.13 0)\"><\/path>\n<\/svg> Share your feedback<\/h2> <div class=\"accordion-section-body collapse \" id=\"content-programme-learning-outcomes-deeper-dive-1\"><p>\n<!-- iframe plugin v.6.0 wordpress.org\/plugins\/iframe\/ -->\n<iframe loading=\"lazy\" class=\"image w-75\" src=\"https:\/\/forms.microsoft.com\/pages\/responsepage.aspx?id=MEu3vWiVVki9vwZ1l3j8vFjmzr0UHJNEkrFqXd1VVfhURFkwR1E4TzlNNFJGR1VIRDdKRENOOFZFSS4u\" width=\"100%\" height=\"500\" scrolling=\"yes\" frameborder=\"0\"><\/iframe>\n<\/p>\n<\/div> <\/div><div class=\"accordion-section\">\n        <h2 class=\"accordion-section-header-title collapsed\" data-toggle=\"collapse\" href=\"#content-programme-learning-outcomes-deeper-dive-2\"\n        aria-expanded=\"false\"><svg class=\"icon icon-chevron-right\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" viewBox=\"0 0 19.75 32\">\n    <title>Chevron right<\/title>\n    <path d=\"M6.13,28.28L18.41,16,6.13,3.72,9.84,0l16,16-16,16Z\" transform=\"translate(-6.13 0)\"><\/path>\n<\/svg> Where next?<\/h2> <div class=\"accordion-section-body collapse \" id=\"content-programme-learning-outcomes-deeper-dive-2\"><p>You are on page 1 of 4 of the 4-stage process for Programme Development.<br \/>\nThe next pages are:<br \/>\n2) <a href=\"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/programme-development\/programme-assessment\/\">Programme Assessment<\/a><br \/>\n3) <a href=\"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/programme-development\/module-learning-outcomes\/\">Module Learning Outcomes<\/a><br \/>\n4) <a href=\"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/programme-development\/module-assessment\/\">Module Assessment<\/a><\/p>\n<p>\u2757 It is strongly recommended if you are designing a new programme or undergoing revalidation that you explore the following pages as you build up your Quality documentation. They are in a fixed order:<\/p>\n<ol>\n<li><a href=\"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/programme-development\/programme-learning-outcomes\/\">Programme Learning Outcomes<\/a><\/li>\n<li><a href=\"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/programme-development\/programme-assessment\/\">Programme Assessment<\/a><\/li>\n<li><a href=\"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/programme-development\/module-learning-outcomes\/\">Module Learning Outcomes<\/a><\/li>\n<li><a href=\"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/programme-development\/module-assessment\/\">Module Assessment<\/a><\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<p>Or you could return to <a href=\"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/programme-development\/\">Programme Development<\/a> and visit the other pages another time.<\/p>\n<\/div> <\/div><\/div>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"Getting started with Programme Learning Outcomes Introduction to the Four-Stage Process Staff are advised to follow an outcomes-based approach to education, that is to directly align the learning outcomes of [&hellip;]","protected":false},"author":8903,"featured_media":0,"parent":27,"menu_order":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","template":"","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[49],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-349","page","type-page","status-publish","hentry","category-programme-development"],"meta_box":{"cu_accordion":"","cu_alert":"","cu_tabs":"","cu_quote":""},"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/pages\/349","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/pages"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/page"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/8903"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=349"}],"version-history":[{"count":36,"href":"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/pages\/349\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":9535,"href":"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/pages\/349\/revisions\/9535"}],"up":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/pages\/27"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=349"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=349"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/sites.cardiff.ac.uk\/education-development-toolkit\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=349"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}